vietnam 1975 afghanistan 2021

The 20-year American presence in Afghanistan ended this week with the mass evacuation of 120,000 Americans and Afghan citizens in only 17 days. In 1978-79, the United States betrayed the pro-U.S. Shah of Iran and embraced Ayatollah Khomeini, assuming that he was pro-U.S., driven by human rights and democracy. Found insideThis book proves Mark Twain’s adage that you cannot have an empire abroad and a republic at home.”—Bruce Cumings, University of Chicago “This book lays the Philippine body politic on the examination table to reveal the disease that ... Israel’s government must subordinate peace-in-our-time dreams to hard Middle East reality. AP "And, in fact, we succeeded a while ago. In Haunting Legacy, the father-daughter journalist team of Marvin Kalb and Deborah Kalb presents a compelling, accessible, and hugely important history of presidential decisionmaking on one crucial issue: in light of the Vietnam debacle, ... Television cameras might well capture a hasty, chaotic U.S. exit from Baghdad in a few years that would again evoke unpleasant memories of Saigon in 1975 and Kabul in 2021. Found inside – Page 1Praised as a “superb scholarly achievement” (Foreign Policy), The Road Not Taken confirms Max Boot’s role as a “master chronicler” (Washington Times) of American military affairs. US Black Hawk military helicopter flies over the . Easily add text to images or memes. Ted Galen Carpenter is a senior fellow in security studies at the Cato Institute and a contributing editor at the National Interest. In light of these realities, this book discusses the challenges and opportunities for the new U.S. administration as well as the EU of re-engaging with a sometimes-troublesome, yet long-time ally. PHOTO 2: US diplomat evacuate the US from embassy via helicopter as the PAVN & Viet Cong capture of Saigon, Vietnam (1975)," tweeted Stefan Simanowitz, an investigative journalist. They called these camps reeducation camps, and families of former regime officials and soldiers faced a sort of black-listing that prevented them from entering colleges and taking certain jobs. Kabul Warning. Found inside – Page iOriginal and trenchantly argued, this book refracts light on the invisible stories of Vietnamese refugees and points us towards new innovative approaches for future inquiries."—Pierrette Hondagneu-Sotelo, author of Paradise Transplanted: ... Also, a common refrain heard by people on the street in Vietnam is this: “Which form of Southeast Asian democracy is preferable to our government? They seek to intimidate the international community all the way to submission, peacefully or militarily. It will be especially interesting to witness what happens in Kabul, for Kabul like Saigon seems to symbolize the promise of a more liberal Afghanistan. … The comity of nations, or the sanctity of treaties, the rules of natural justice, or decent respect for the opinions of mankind, are quite alien and largely unintelligible to the Middle East (The Chatham House Version, pp 1-12).”. In 2021, the United States faces only the choice of whether to confront Islamic terrorists on their own territory or shift the war to American soil. This combination photo shared by Human Rights Minister Shireen Mazari shows Americans being evacuated by helicopters in Vietnam's Saigon in 1975 (left) and Kabul in Afghanistan (right) this week. Found insideA survey of the Vietnamese communist experience during the Vietnam War (1954-75) with a focus on high-level decision-making and military planning. In 1975, the United States was involved in a civil war in Vietnam. Harnage) helps Vietnamese evacuees onto an Air America helicopter from the top of 22 Gia Long St., a half-mile from the U.S. Embassy on April 29, 1975. Actually, America never made the right choices in either war because the decision-makers didn't understand what war they were fighting. Source: News.cgtn.com, August 22, 2021) In this April 12, 1975 file photo, U.S. Marines provide cover during Operation Eagle Pull as Americans and Cambodians board Marine helicopters in Phnom Penh during the final U.S. pullout of . The US disengagement from Afghanistan, along with its eagerness to reenter the 2015 nuclear accord with Iran’s Ayatollahs, the enhanced ties with the Muslim Brotherhood in the Middle East and the US, and the US pressure exerts on Saudi Arabia, the UAE and Egypt, may drive these pro-US Arab regimes closer to China and Russia, which are major beneficiaries of the current US policy. First, Afghanistan. In 1975, the US disengagement from Vietnam fulfilled the goal of the Viet Cong, thus ending the US-Vietnam conflict. . South Vietnamese civilians scaling a U.S. Embassy wall in a desperate attempt to leave the country aboard evacuation flights from Saigon in 1975. . Afghanistan (2021). As Kabul fell, . I guess a similar thing might happen in Afghanistan. Vietnam veteran who earned the Medal of Honor says Afghanistan now looks 'just like' Saigon in 1975 insider@insider.com (John Haltiwanger) 8/13/2021 Some Texas residents are stockpiling . In 2021, the 14-century-old vision and strategic goal of Islamic terrorism are not limited to the territory of Afghanistan. Indonesia?” So long as the country’s economy is booming and people are better off than in the “dark days” after 1975, I don’t see much significant interest in democratization. Modeled on the classic Vietnam War book, War Comes to Long An, Carter Malkasian's War Comes to Garmser promises to be a landmark account of the long war in Afghanistan, which has lasted with a few brief interludes of truce from 1979 to the ... In Saigon in 1975, U.S. aircraft ferried more than . Islamic terrorism is determined to establish a global Islamic society, ruled by the Quran and Sharia (“divine law”), which is inconsistent with peaceful-coexistence with the “infidel” US, irrespective of its involvement in Afghanistan. Afghanistan in 2021. Vietnam’s economy plummeted into a devastating economic depression as it tried to rebuild shattered infrastructure, re-green defoliated forests, and replace aging industries. Saigon, which was later renamed as Ho Chi Minh City, fell on April 30, 1975, signalling the end of the Vietnam War, and the Communists consolidated their hold over the entire country in the next few months. Islamic terrorists don’t seek popularity in the international community. The home is owned by Thuy Do, who was nine years old when her family arrived in the United States from Vietnam in . COVID-19 and return to campus information. The scenes in Kabul this week . Our ability to cover the most important issues in Israel and throughout the Jewish world—without the standard media bias—depends on the support of committed readers. In 1980-90, the United States collaborated with Saddam Hussein, assuming that “the enemy [Iraq] of my enemy [Iran] is my friend,” naively providing a green light for his invasion of Kuwait. In 1975, the vision and strategic goal of the Viet Cong was limited to the territory of Vietnam, consistent with an eventual peaceful-coexistence and cooperation with the resourceful US. With geographic, political and social divides growing wider, high-quality reporting and informed analysis are more important than ever to keep people connected. I think the news of direct talks between senior American and Taliban officials signals that neither side, the U.S. or Afghanistan’s new government, want to repeat the diplomatic isolation that followed the fall of Saigon. It's bad enough that Kabul in 2021 is an acid-trip of bad nostalgia to Saigon in 1975. The world today, especially in the Middle East, is very different geopolitically, and I think the competitive presence of other powers — China, Russia, Pakistan, the Emirates, India, and the U.S. — means that we may see the possibility for a quicker reconciliation process between Afghanistan’s new government and the international community. Afghanistan in 2021 and South Vietnam in 1975 are far from one-for-one comparisons, and Cohn clarified that he has no idea how whether what's happening in Kabul will affect Biden's approval rating . … The Muslim theory of international relations recognizes only two possible situations: war on the ‘infidel’ or his subjugation to the ‘faithful.’ Peace with him de jure is hostility until he recognizes the authority of the Muslim ruler. Hanoi's War renders transparent the internal workings of America's most elusive enemy during the Cold War and shows that the war fought during the peace negotiations was bloodier and much more wide ranging than it had been previously. Those polices lasted for more than 20 years after the fall of Saigon. A. That may be hard to grasp given the overwhelming technological presence of American (and other foreign) forces, but everyone knew the foreign troops would eventually leave and all that would be left were Vietnamese combatants and their families to pick up the pieces amid the ruins. Who will be the next 'ally' abandoned by the U.S.?" Depicting The U.S. As Caring Only For Its Own Interests. The book will stand for the foreseeable future as the best study of the tragic mistakes that led to so much suffering."—Robert Dallek Many books have been written on the tragic decisions regarding Vietnam made by the young stars of the ... In 2021, the US disengagement from Afghanistan advances - but does not fulfill - the goal of the Taliban and Al Qaeda, and therefore does not end the . Found inside – Page 453War of 1812 (1812–1814), the Mexican War (1846–1848), the Spanish-American War ... Vietnam (1964–1975), Afghanistan (2001–2021), and Iraq (1991, 2003–2011). The Vietnam operation, dubbed Operation Frequent Wind, saw more than 7,000 Vietnamese civilians evacuated from Saigon on 29 and 30 April 1975 by helicopter. SAIGON, VIETNAM 1975 AFGHANISTAN 2021; YARA MAN; To all those who died / maimed fighting for "freedom" and your families, sorry we did not learn from HISTORY! David Hackworth, author of About Face). In November 1965, some 450 men of the First Battalion, Seventh Cavalry, under the command of Lt. Col. Harold Moore, were dropped into a small clearing in the Ia Drang Valley. On April 18, 1975, while explaining his opposition to the Vietnam Contingency Act of 1975, which would have provided funds for these efforts, Biden said he believed that "the only objective of . Moreover, rogue regimes are not impressed by US diplomacy, as they are by effective US counter-terrorism and posture of deterrence. PHOTO 1: US diplomat evacuate US from embassy via helicopter as the #Taliban enter #Kabul from all sides. But a Vietnam veteran who earned the Medal of Honor said the current situation is "just like Vietnam in 1975." The Taliban is making rapid gains, pushing the US to evacuate the embassy in Kabul. Experts fear that the Taliban can do the same in Afghanistan in near future. A quick review of the past 50 years reveals a dismal pattern of American betrayal and lack of accountability leaving behind suffering and failed states. Vietnam fell in 1975. For years, overseas Vietnamese were treated as suspects or “traitors” by the communist government in Vietnam, but as the government relaxed rules on remittances — the funds overseas immigrants send to family back home — they witnessed an incredible influx of foreign currency and investment. VIETNAM - CIRCA 1975: War of Vietnam. “If Afghanistan’s government can somehow leapfrog its immediate economic and political troubles into this more worldly, friendly, and liberal future, then maybe there is hope for a kind of Vietnam-like ending.”. I was a 17-year-old Saigon boy in April 1975 when the Americans hurriedly left and South Vietnam collapsed. Despite recent violence from ISIS-K extremists, the evacuation from Kabul did not approach the same level of violence or chaos. I was in third grade in Saigon in the spring of 1975.Dad, a former South Vietnamese lieutenant fluent in several languages, was a managing editor of an English-language weekly called the Vietnam Sun. We know from declassified documents that CIA, military, and State Department officials argued for weeks about how many Vietnamese refugees to accept, and I imagine in 30 years, we’ll find the same thing happened in Kabul. Afghanistan’s new rulers may also emulate the Vietnamese government’s policy on overseas diasporas. The U.S. disengagement from Afghanistan, along with its eagerness to reenter the 2015 nuclear accord with Iran’s ayatollahs, the enhanced ties with the Muslim Brotherhood in the Middle East and the United States, and pressure the United States exerts on Saudi Arabia, the UAE and Egypt, may drive these pro-U.S. Arab regimes closer to China and Russia, which are major beneficiaries of the current U.S. policy. Immediately after the war, the new government was quick to identify and imprison some 100,000 former government and South Vietnamese military fighters. Videos of Afghan civilians clinging to military aircraft summoned images of evacuees clambering aboard helicopters in Saigon as the city fell to the North Vietnamese army in 1975. For students of history and those old enough to remember, the rapidity with which the Taliban captured the Afghan capital of Kabul evoked memories of the April 1975 fall of Saigon, the South Vietnamese capital. The U.S. failed in its mission (in Vietnam) to contain communism and prop up a noncommunist regime, and I would brand any campaign that cost 50,000 American lives and more than 4 million Vietnamese lives a failure in humanitarian, economic, and political terms. In 2021, the U.S. disengagement from Afghanistan advances—but does not fulfil The Taliban celebrated . The fall of Kabul, Afghanistan, to the Taliban has inevitably drawn comparisons to the 1975 "fall of Saigon"—so many that, on Sunday, Secretary of State Antony Blinken told the press . Philippines? America lost two wars it chose not to win. The comity of nations, or the sanctity of treaties, the rules of natural justice, or decent respect for the opinions of mankind, are quite alien and largely unintelligible to the Middle East (. United States Army in Vietnam. Published: Aug. 18, 2021 at 5:24 PM PDT. We asked UC Riverside history professor, award-winning author, and Vietnam scholar David Biggs to reflect on the recent, troubled exodus from Kabul, and what lessons Vietnam may hold for post-occupation Afghanistan. For Vietnam, the biggest key was the Soviet Union’s collapse. In 1975, the vision and strategic goal of the Viet Cong was limited to the territory of Vietnam, consistent with an eventual peaceful coexistence and cooperation with the United States. In 2021, against the backdrop of a gradual U.S. withdrawal from the geo-strategically critical Middle East and the intensifying threats to regional stability, Israel stands out as the most effective, reliable and democratic beachhead and force multiplier for the United States, and the most effective “life insurance agent” for all pro-U.S. Arab regimes. Images of Saigon in 1975 keep appearing in minds and on TV screens, but let's not forget the collapse of the American-trained Iraqi military in 2014. There are lessons for Afghanistan in Vietnam's eventual prosperity, expert says. August 16, 2021. (August 19, 2021 / JNS) In 1975, the U.S. disengagement from Vietnam fulfilled the goal of the Viet Cong, thus ending the U.S.-Vietnam conflict. In 2011, the US led the NATO offensive against Qaddafi, which transformed Libya into a major platform of global Islamic terrorism and civil wars. The . To the extent that leaders were not corrupt and military actions didn’t destroy that civilian infrastructure, those contributions and people-to-people ties went a long way towards effecting positive, nonviolent change in Vietnam. With the Afghanistan evacuation crisis still unfolding, it may seem odd to suddenly blame President Joe Biden for the fall of Vietnam. BISMARCK, N.D. (KFYR) - The Taliban has taken control of the government in Afghanistan, and as the United States military leaves the country, the world is . After all, that happened 46 years ago! Easily add text to images or memes. Islamic terrorism is determined to establish a global Islamic society, ruled by the Koran and Sharia (“Divine law”). Kabul, Afghanistan Like Saigon, Vietnam 1975 1st Order Observation. For the new state in Afghanistan, the challenges have just begun and there are important lessons from Vietnam’s postwar history. Found inside – Page 104Afghanistan Crisis: Why US withdrawal from Kabul is being compared to fall of ... Saigon's capture had marked the end of the Vietnam War and the start of a ... It turns out that a special product of America's military-industrial-Congressional complex is junk militaries, whether in Vietnam in 1975 or Iraq in 2014 or Afghanistan in 2021. In 1978/79, the US betrayed the pro-US Shah of Iran and embraced the Ayatollah Khomeini, assuming that he was pro-US, driven by human rights and democracy. OPINION: Vietnam, Afghanistan; Saigon, Kabul. Vietnam fell in 1975. The views expressed in guest columns are not necessarily the views or positions of the CCNS or its members. — Howard Mortman (@HowardMortman) August 16, 2021. Header photo by Jim Kelly, Flickr Commons, 900 University Ave. Thus, the US retreat has intensified existential threats to every pro-US Arab regime (e.g., Saudi Arabia, the UAE, Bahrain, Oman, Jordan, Egypt, Morocco). Abdul, right, who worked as a mechanic before he left Kabul, Afghanistan with his family about a month ago, shows his family a donated tea kettle as they stand in the kitchen of a rental house, Thursday, Sept. 16, 2021, that has been provided as a place for them to stay in Seattle. In May 2021, largely . For example, in 1948, the State Department determined that the newly-born Jewish State would be helpless against a concerted Arab military assault, would be pro-Soviet and undermine US-Arab relations. The 20-year American presence in Afghanistan ended this week with the mass evacuation of 120,000 Americans and Afghan . They seek to intimidate the international community into submission, peacefully or otherwise. Finally. The Biden administration apparently doesn't know the meaning of the word "optics.". Déjà Vu: Saigon, Vietnam, 1975; Kabul, Afghanistan, 2021. hotkeys: D = random, W = upvote, S = downvote, A = back The evacuation of . This book uses new evidence from long hidden communist sources to show that, in fact, Poland was authorized by Hanoi to open direct contacts and that Hanoi had committed to entering talks with Washington. In 2021, the US is fighting against an intrinsic, anti-US Islamic terrorism, faced with the choice of confronting Islamic terrorists in their own trenches (which is costly), or disengaging and gradually shifting the war to the US trenches (which is dramatically costlier). Afghanistan, Aug. 16, 2021. 2021 Afghanistan is not 1975 Vietnam The differences run deep, despite superficial similarites and show the Afghanistan retreat to be a much more negative game changer. In 2021, in view of the Afghanistan and Gaza experience and the. This volume examines the origins and early years of the Cold War in the first comprehensive historical reexamination of the period. This article was originally published at The Ettinger Report. Similarly, the capture of Saigon was preceded by the evacuation of almost all American civilian and military personnel in Saigon, along with tens of thousands of South Vietnamese civilians who had been associated with the Republic of Vietnam. Meticulously researched and movingly told, A Better War sheds new light on the Vietnam War. The evacuation of . During the 1950s, the United States courted Egyptian President Gamal Abdel Nasser, who downplayed the lavish U.S. offers and became an ardent pro-Soviet and anti-U.S. leader. Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted. I think there may be lessons there for the Taliban. That’s a tough question. August 16, 2021 by Ronald Yates. Afghanistan photos from 2021 remind of the Vietnam War 1975 - Kabul is the new Saigon - domestic politics News Stephanie News Sunday 15th August 2021 10:38 AM 50 REPORT "Under no circumstances will we see people being flown out of the roof of the US embassy in Afghanistan."

Windsor Park Columbus Ohio, Linear Programming And Its Applications Pdf, Atem Software Control No Switcher Connected, Kpmg Machine Learning Jobs, Who Won The Pac-12 Football Championship, Best Walks In The Lake District For Families,